Is a kitchen really a kitchen if it doesn’t have a sheet pan (or five)? Metal baking trays are versatile workhorses, handling everything from chocolate chip cookies to roasted vegetables to entire sheet-pan dinners. Sure, you might think a bit of metal is just a bit of metal. How different can sheet pans be? But not all are created equal, and for a piece of kitchen equipment as vital as a baking tray, you’ll want to make sure you’re getting one that will serve you well and last for years.
Our Platonic sheet pan is no wallflower. We need it to be durable enough to use daily without warping under high heat, high-quality so that your food cooks exactly at the rate it should, and the right size to fit in most home ovens. For all that and more, we turn to the inimitable Nordic Ware Naturals Aluminum Half-Sheet. It’s the best sheet pan on the market—and the BA test kitchen’s agreed-upon all-time favorite.
Nordic Ware Half-Sheet Pan
Why is the Nordic Ware Naturals Aluminum Half-Sheet our pick for best sheet pan?
Our crowd-favorite baking sheet is made with pure light-colored uncoated aluminum, which conducts heat more efficiently and uniformly than aluminized steel (aluminum-coated steel) or stainless steel. This results in food that bakes evenly, rises predictably, and browns perfectly—meaning, when you put a tray of choc chip cookies in the oven, they start baking straightaway on your aluminum sheet pan and stop baking as soon as you pull them out. Nobody likes a burnt-bottom biscuit!
Made from heavy-gauge (read: thick) aluminum, these sheets are also our pick for durability. Metal expands when heated, and under extreme temperatures a thin, rimless baking sheet might turn into something that looks more at home in a sculpture garden than your kitchen. Something called a “reinforced encapsulated steel rim” is the secret weapon to making Nordic Ware’s baking trays extremely warp-resistant. The edge of the aluminum tray is rolled around a rectangular frame of steel wire, which pushes against the four sides and keeps the bottom flat, making sure your pan stays level and absorbs heat evenly.
This half-sheet is also mess-free. The one-inch high edge, like a dam levee, keeps olive oil from sloshing everywhere, sheet-pan dinner juices from spilling, rising dough from expanding off the edge, and crispy little veggie bits from ending up in bottom-of-the-oven purgatory—all of which makes for an easier cleanup later.
The coziest little butternuts
So, what size pan should I buy? What is the difference between a sheet pan and a jelly roll pan and a cookie sheet? Help, I’m spiraling.
When it comes to sheet pans, size matters. Typically, we recommend a half-sheet pan, or half-size sheet pan, which is about 18x13" and is big enough for most home cooks but small enough to fit easily into your apartment oven. Unless you are a commercial baker, when you read a recipe that calls for a sheet pan, this is the size in question.
Nordic Ware Half-Sheet Pan
Full sheet pans, the ones you see used in restaurant kitchens and commercial bakeries, are actually ginormous (26x18") and won’t fit in most home kitchen ovens. But if you need to cook for a crowd, the Nordic Ware Big Sheet Baking Pan, at 21x15", is your fighter. It’s 35% larger than the classic half-sheet pan and still fits most standard-size ovens. Made from aluminum, it’s a trusty pan that you can count on for the long haul.
Then there arequarter-sheet pans. At 13x9", their surface area is half the size of a half-sheet pan’s, naturally, and they’re great for when you’re roasting a portion of small portion of veg, toasting nuts or seeds, baking a “I’m having a hard day” cookie for one, or storing meat in the fridge. For a small but mighty tray, don’t look past the Nordic Ware Bakers Quarter-Sheet Pans. They’re staples in restaurant kitchens and virtually guaranteed to make you a better, faster cook.
Nordic Ware Quarter-Sheet Pans, 2-Pack
While cookie sheets are often referred to as baking sheets, there is a difference. At best, they have one or two slightly raised edges—like this Vollrath Wear-Ever Cookie Sheet Pan—but typically they are totally flat. This feat of design excellence allows hot cookies to slide off the tray easily without ruining their shape. But never, ever roast on these! They’re more susceptible to warping and your meat juices and oils will be very everywhere.
Vollrath Wear-Ever Cookie Sheet Pan
For the pastry chefs among us: A jelly roll pan is another thing altogether. At 15x10" in size, a jelly roll pan is larger than a quarter-sheet pan and smaller than a half-sheet pan. If you make a lot of roulades, go ahead and buy one rather than trying to scale up or down your recipes. Sure, they make for dainty spirals of sponge cake, but they’re also a great size for baking just about anything.
Nordic Ware Jelly Roll Pan
What’s the deal with stainless steel and nonstick sheet pans?
As you can tell from our top picks above, we’re team aluminum. While stainless steel cookware works wonders on the stovetop, it’s not ideal for baking for a few reasons. First, it isn’t as good at conducting heat as aluminum—it heats up and cools down more slowly, which means your food will take longer to reach temperature and will continue to cook once it’s removed from the oven. The darker color of stainless steel also makes it more difficult to control the browning of your baked goods and more prone to uneven cooking.
